Should I buy inventory based on personal taste or sales data?
Let sales data drive your reorder depth. Express your personal taste through curation, styling, and merchandising — but buy deep on what actually sells.
“Buy one for your heart, buy twelve for your register. That should be on a poster in every buying office.”
This is one of the most common tensions boutique owners face: your favorite pieces aren't always your bestsellers. One boutique owner discovered that seven of her top ten SKUs were plain solid tees she found boring to sell — but they flew off the shelves. The exercise that reveals this is simple: make two columns labeled 'I'd Wear This' and 'This Actually Sells,' then compare the overlap.
The resolution is to let the register decide your reorder depth. Buy one unit of something you love to keep your store's personality and creative vision intact. Buy twelve units of what the data proves your customers want. Your personal taste gets expressed in curation, styling, content creation, and the experience of walking into a beautifully merchandised space — it just shouldn't dictate how many units you order.
This also applies to ad creative. Many boutiques run aspirational lifestyle shots of new arrivals while their actual proven bestsellers aren't featured in any active campaign. Point your ad dollars at the validated winners first.
Listen to the full episode: Episode 26: The Mid-Year Boutique Audit: 6 Numbers to Pull Before You Plan Your July-August Strategy
More answers from this episode
- How do I calculate email revenue per send for my boutique?
- How do I calculate gross margin by product category in Shopify?
- How do I decide which vendors to stop buying from?
- How do I find my top selling products in Shopify?
- How do I identify dead stock in my boutique inventory?
- How do I run a mid-year audit for my boutique?
Source: BoutiquePulse podcast. Last updated: 2026-06-08 · Sourcing & methodology · Corrections log