How do I check if my email deliverability is hurting my boutique sales?
If your open rate is below 15 percent on recent campaigns, deliverability is likely a problem. Build a segment of 90-day non-openers — if it's more than 20 percent of your total list, your domain reputation is being damaged.
“When more than twenty percent of your list hasn't opened anything in ninety days, ISPs throttle your delivery. Your domain reputation tanks.”
Poor deliverability is a silent killer because you never see the emails that land in spam — they just disappear. The fastest diagnostic is your open rate on recent campaigns. If it's consistently below 15 percent, your list health is probably dragging you down.
To get a clearer picture, log into your email platform and create a segment of subscribers who haven't opened or clicked any email in the last 90 days. Compare that segment's size to your total list. If inactive subscribers represent more than 20 percent of your list, internet service providers are likely throttling your sends and routing emails to spam for everyone, including the subscribers who actually want to hear from you.
The fix is a re-engagement campaign: send one honest email to the inactive segment with a single button that says 'Yes, Keep Me On the List' and a note that non-responders will be removed in seven days. Then actually suppress the non-responders. This is especially critical before launching time-sensitive sequences like a post-holiday campaign, where every email that reaches an engaged inbox directly impacts revenue.
Listen to the full episode: Episode 18: The Post-Mother's Day Week: Turn Gift Recipients Into Your Most Loyal Repeat Customers
More answers from this episode
- How do I bridge Mother's Day marketing into Father's Day sales?
- How do I reach a gift recipient if they never signed up for my email list?
- How do I run a social media contest to grow my email list after a holiday?
- How do I set up a post-holiday email sequence in Klaviyo or Omnisend?
- How do I structure a loyalty program for my boutique without killing my margins?
- How do I turn Mother's Day gift recipients into repeat customers?
Source: BoutiquePulse podcast. Last updated: 2026-05-13 · Sourcing & methodology · Corrections log